|
|
||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CLINICAL STUDY |
Departments of1 , Endocrinology2 Rheumatology, Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands3 Department of Internal Medicine, Medical Centre Alkmaar, Alkmaar, The Netherlands
(Correspondence should be addressed to J W Smit who is now at Department of Endocrinology and Metabolic Diseases, Leiden University Medical Centre, PO Box 9600, 2300 RC Leiden, The Netherlands; Email: j.w.a.smit{at}lumc.nl)
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: We performed a prospective, 26-week phase II study with open-ended observations.
Methods: Thirteen patients with relapsing Graves' disease (9 females and 4 males, age 39.5±9.5 years) received 2 dosages of rituximab 1000 mg i.v. with a 2-week interval. Before administration and on several periods after the administration of TSH, free thyroxine (FT4), thyrotropin binding inhibitory immunoglobulins (TBII) and the proportion of CD19 and MS4A1 positive peripheral blood mononuclear cells were measured.
Results: The proportion of MS4A1 positive lymphocytes decreased in all patients from 5.8% at baseline to 1.4% at 26 weeks (P=0.007). Four patients with high initial FT4 levels did not respond to treatment. All remaining patients had a decrease in FT4 levels at 26 weeks (P=0.001) and an increase in TSH levels (P=0.011). TBII decreased in all remaining patients (P=0.003). At a follow-up time of 14–27 months, nine of these patients were still euthyroid with normal FT4 (P<0.001) and TSH levels (P=0.008).
Conclusions: The present study results suggest a beneficial role of rituximab in mild relapsing Graves' disease. A subsequent randomized controlled trial with rituximab is recommended.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A promising strategy in autoimmune diseases is the elimination of activated B-lymphocytes. MS4A1 is highly expressed on the surface of pre-B lymphocytes as well as activated mature B-lymphocytes (9), which makes the MS4A1 antigen an attractive target for various disorders involving B-cell activation. In addition to abolishing immunoglobulin production, anti-MS4A1 therapy could also interfere with the antigen-presenting role of B-cells (10). B-cells are also able to modulate T cell activities. rituximab is a chimeric monoclonal antibody specific for human MS4A1 (9, 11, 12). rituximab was the first therapeutic monoclonal antibody used for the treatment of non-Hodgkin lymphoma (13, 14). It has subsequently been successfully applied in various autoimmune diseases (15), including idiopathic thrombocytic purpura (16), systemic lupus erythematosus (17, 18), haemolytic anaemia (19) and rheumatoid arthritis (10, 20, 21).
Recently, a few papers have been published on the effectiveness of rituximab in Graves' ophthalmopathy and hyperthyroidism (22, 23, 24). In a study of nine patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy, rituximab positively affected the clinical course without influencing thyroid function (22). El Fassi et al. (23) have recently published a study of 20 patients, with mostly a first episode of Graves' disease. rituximab in combination with methimazole induced a sustained remission in 4/10 patients, whereas all patients treated with methimazole alone relapsed. Because methimazole treatment in this study was
4 months, which is unusually short, it is not clear whether rituximab would be more efficacious when compared with a full course of methimazole therapy.
We decided to perform a phase II pilot study with rituximab in patients with recurrent Graves' disease. We chose to study recurrent Graves' disease instead of a first episode of Graves' disease because these patients are treated with radioiodine therapy that ultimately leads to hypothyroidism in most patients. We therefore considered any ability of rituximab to prevent radioiodine treatment an important health benefit.
| Patients and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Seventeen consecutive patients with relapsing Graves' disease were recruited from patients who were referred to the Department of Nuclear Medicine of the Leiden University Medical Centre for radioiodine therapy because of relapsing Graves' disease. Exclusion criteria were serious signs or symptoms of hyperthyroidism requiring immediate conventional therapy, other conditions or concomitant medication that could interfere with the study objectives, such as the use of corticosteroids for obstructive pulmonary disease, and contraindications for the use of rituximab such as previous treatment with murine monoclonal antibodies. Four patients refused rituximab treatment. Therefore, 13 patients (9 females and 4 males, age 39.5±9.5 years) entered the study.
A prior episode of Graves' disease had to be confirmed by documented elevated serum free thyroxine (FT4) levels, suppressed serum TSH levels, a typical pattern of diffusely increased uptake of Technetium 99m pertechnetate at thyroid scintigraphy and/or elevated serum levels of binding thyrotropin inhibitory immunoglobulins (TBII). Patients had to be adequately treated for prior episodes of Graves' disease with at least 1-year antithyroid drugs. Relapse of Graves' disease after suspension of antithyroid drugs had to be confirmed by hyperthyroidism defined as suppressed TSH levels (<0.4 mU/l), coming from normal levels and increasing or elevated serum FT4 levels.
Eleven patients had a first relapse. Two patients had a second relapse (nos. 7 and 10). Their first relapse was treated with radioiodine (no. 7, radioiodine 8 months before relapse; no. 10, radioiodine 3 years before relapse). Median (range) clinical activity score of Graves' ophthalmopathy was 0 (0–2) points at baseline. Three patients had a NOSPECS score of 2a3040. Median (range) thyroid volume was 20 (20–40) cc. Median time since the first episode of Graves' disease was 19 (14–66) months. The median (range) duration between withdrawal of antithyroid drugs and relapsing Graves' disease was 2 months (1–24 months). Ten patients were treated temporarily with methimazole 30 mg/day after being diagnosed with relapsing Graves' disease. These drugs were discontinued at least 4 weeks prior to rituximab administration to verify the existence of hyperthyroidism before treatment with rituximab. Four patients (nos. 1, 2, 8 and 10) had FT4 levels within the reference range. However, FT4 levels were higher than before relapse in all 4 patients (FT4 before relapse, respectively, 12.1; 16.1; 12.2 and 19.5 pmol/l). Likewise, TSH levels were lower than before relapse in all 4 patients (respectively, 0.210; 0.341; 2.05 and 1.28 mU/l). Median serum levels of TBII were 4.1 IU/l (range 0.2–17.1 IU/l).
The local ethics committees approved the study as a preliminary phase II study, and written informed consent was obtained from all subjects.
Study design
The study was a prospective, open trial with a 26-week duration, with an open-ended observational extension afterwards. The primary endpoint was the absence of hyperthyroidism at the end of the study period (week 26 counted from the first rituximab infusion). The secondary endpoint was the relapse free survival time. Rescue therapy with antithyroid drugs followed by radioiodine was allowed when patients did not respond to rituximab, but this was considered a treatment failure.
Experimental protocol
Patients received two dosages of rituximab 1000 mg i.v. with a 2-week interval. This treatment schedule was based on the treatment schedule used in rheumatoid arthritis (20). To avoid allergic reactions, 10 mg dexamethasone and 2 mg clemastine was given intravenously before the rituximab injection. Study visits took place before the rituximab administration, 1 week after the first administration and at 2–4 week intervals after the second administration. At these visits, a physical examination was performed, including thyroid size estimation. Blood samples were taken for study parameters, including TSH, FT4, TBII and the proportion of CD19 and MS4A1 positive peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). Safety parameters consisted of a haematological profile, serum levels of sodium, potassium and creatinine, lipids, renal and liver function and parameters of bone metabolism. Plasma and serum samples were handled immediately or stored at –80 °C in Sarstedt tubes.
Blood chemistry
FT4 was measured on a Modular Analytics E-170 (Roche Diagnostic Systems; intra-assay variability: 2.47–7.57%, inter-assay variability: 5.6–12.4% at different levels, normal range 10–24 pmol/l). TSH was determined with a Modular Analytics E-170 (Roche Diagnostic Systems), intra-assay variability: 0.88–10.66%, inter-assay variability: 0.91–12.05%, normal range 0.4–4.8 mU/l). FT3 was measured on a Modular Analytics E-170 (Roche Diagnostic Systems, reference range 3.9–6.7 pmol/l). TBII were measured with a TRAb enzyme-immunoassay, using coated recombinant human TSH receptor and biotin labelled human TSH (Medizym T.R.A. kit, Medipan, Berlin, Germany; functional assay sensitivity is 0.2 IU/l). TBII levels above 2.0 IU/l and below 1.0 IU/l indicate positive and negative results according to the manufacturer.
Flow cytometric analysis
PBMC were prepared by centrifugation over Ficoll-Hypaque gradients and cryopreserved in liquid nitrogen. Cells were labelled for 30 min at 4 °C, using anti-MS4A1 fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) (clone 2H7), anti-CD19PE (clone H1B19) and anti-CD3 allophycocyanin (APC) (clone UCHT1) (Beckton Dickinson, San Diego, CA, USA). All stained cells were analysed with a FACSCalibur (Becton Dickinson) flow cytometer and the associated software program FlowJo (Tree Star Inc., Ashland, OR, USA) was used to calculate frequencies within the lymphocyte population. B cells were identified as CD3– and CD19+ cells.
Sample size calculation
To calculate the required sample size, we used the algorithm proposed by Simon et al. for phase II trials (25). Adopting a p0 (absence of efficacy) of 0.20 and a p1 (presence of efficacy) of 0.40. With
and β values of 0.05 and 0.80, respectively, the treatment is rejected if 3 or fewer out of 13 patients respond to the treatment. In this setting, the likelihood of rejecting the treatment in case p0 is true is 75%. In other words, if four or more patients responded, the treatment was considered worthwhile to further explore. Response was defined as euthyroidism at the end of the study period (primary objective, 26 weeks) or relapse-free survival (secondary objective).
Statistical analysis
Values are presented as mean±S.D. or as median (range). Data between groups are analysed by one-way ANOVA and independent sample tests for nonparametric data. Data within groups are analysed by repeated measures ANOVA. SPSS 12.0 for Windows (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) was used for all analyses. Differences were considered statistically significant at P<0.05.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
According to the criteria for success as defined in the Patients and methods section, the criterion of more than three patients being euthyroid was reached. We therefore consider the treatment worthwhile to further explore.
The most obvious question is whether the effects observed can be attributed to rituximab therapy. The natural course of relapsing Graves' disease is not known, as most patients with relapsing Graves' disease will receive treatment. The generally accepted notion that therapy with antithyroid drugs does not provide a definite cure in relapsing Graves' disease is the base for definite therapies consisting of radioiodine or surgery. This notion makes it very unlikely that nine patients, in whom radioiodine therapy was indicated, would resolve spontaneously. In addition, all patients had increasing serum FT4 and decreasing serum TSH levels at the time of treatment. It is unlikely that this course would have changed spontaneously in all patients. We therefore believe that the effects observed can be attributed to rituximab. These findings are in agreement with the conclusions of El Fassi et al. (23) who found a beneficial effects of rituximab in patients who in the majority had a first episode of Graves' disease, but differs from the observations in patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy, where no effect on hyperthyroidism was found (22, 24).
The four patients who did not respond had highly elevated FT4 levels. It seems therefore likely that the beneficial effect of rituximab in our study was limited to those patients with relapsing Graves' disease in an early phase. In the study of El Fassi et al. (23), FT4 levels did not differ between responders and non-responders, however, in that study, all patients were pretreated with methimazole. The explanation for differences in the efficacy of rituximab in patients with relatively low versus high serum FT4 levels is complicated as the working mechanism of rituximab in the context of Graves' disease is incompletely understood. Aspects relevant for the efficacy of rituximab include pharmacokinetic effects (rituximab half-life may be influenced by the degree of hyperthyroidism), pharmacodynamic aspects (differences in dose-effect relationships and susceptibility at the level of developing B-cells, differences in half-lives of activated B-cells, differences in tissue penetration of rituximab and differences in the degree of plasma cell and T-lymphocyte activation, given the fact that rituximab does not directly affect plasma cells or T-lymphocytes). It could furthermore be hypothesized that the response to rituximab was dependent on the interval between withdrawal from antithyroid drugs and relapse. However, this relationship was not obvious from our data, although the small number of patients prevents a definite conclusion.
We observed a clear decrease in TBII levels in patients with a favourable outcome, whereas TBII levels remained elevated in non-responders. However, a clear relationship between serum TBII levels and outcome could not be studied because of the small number of patients in our study. It would be useful to study this further to define a subgroup of patients likely or not to be responders. El Fassi et al. found a relation between baseline TBII levels and rituximab effectiveness, patients with lower TBII levels responding more favourably (23). However, they did not find an effect of rituximab on TBII in comparison with methimazole. In addition, no correlation was found between proportions of CD-20+ lymphocytes and TBII levels. This is in agreement with the study of Salvi et al. (24) and El Fassi et al. (23). In fact, it is well documented that there is no linear relationship between serum TBII concentrations and serum FT4 levels in patients with Graves' disease (1), as TBII are a heterogeneous pool of both stimulating and blocking antibodies.
All patients showed a marked decrease in CD19– and MS4A1 positive lymphocytes, irrespective of outcome. Apparently, no clear relation exists between the degree of depletion of MS4A1 positive cells from peripheral blood and the therapeutic effect. The relation between circulating levels of MS4A1 positive lymphocytes, serological markers of autoimmune disease and effectiveness of rituximab in autoimmune disease is complex, but a number of studies suggest an inverse relationship between proportions of B-cells, autoantibody titres and therapeutic effect in rheumatoid arthritis and lupus (10, 17, 26, 27). In our study, the proportion of CD-20 positive lymphocytes was not associated with TBII levels. As discussed by Salvi et al. (24) and El Fassi et al. (23) synthesis of new antibodies occurs after rituximab treatment given that the half life of human IgG is
3 weeks. This and the absence of a beneficial effect of rituximab in some patients may be related to the fact that an important source of auto antibodies is plasma cells that do not express MS4A1. In addition, a fraction of plasma cells have a very slow turnover (28). In addition, B cell depletion may be less pronounced in lymphoid cells in germinal centres in the thyroid (29) as discussed by El Fassi and Salvi (23, 24). However, El Fassi found complete intrathyroidal B-lymphocyte depletion (30).
In summary, we found indications for a beneficial effect of rituximab in patients with relapsing Graves' disease with mild hyperthyroidism. As this was a phase II study, these results need to be confirmed in a randomized study. In addition, the issue of safety is still a concern given a recent report by the FDA, which reported an increased risk of progressive multifocal leucoencephalopathy (http://www.fda.gov/CDER/Drug/InfoSheets/HCP/rituximab.pdf). Although the high cost of rituximab may limit its use in first episodes of Graves' disease, preventing hospital admission for radioiodine therapy may grant rituximab a more prominent place in the treatment of relapsing Graves' disease, when the efficacy can be confirmed.
| Declaration of interest |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Funding |
|---|
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. V. Misharin, Y. Nagayama, H. A. Aliesky, Y. Mizutori, B. Rapoport, and S. M. McLachlan Attenuation of Induced Hyperthyroidism in Mice by Pretreatment with Thyrotropin Receptor Protein: Deviation of Thyroid-Stimulating to Nonfunctional Antibodies Endocrinology, August 1, 2009; 150(8): 3944 - 3952. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |