|
|
||||||||
CLINICAL STUDIES |
1 Department of Sexology and Gender Problems, Ghent University Hospital, Belgium2 Department of Endocrinology, Ghent University Hospital Belgium3 Department of Gynaecology, Ghent University Hospital, Belgium and 4 Center of Gender Dysphoria, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
(Correspondence should be addressed to G T'Sjoen; Email: guy.tsjoen{at}ugent.be)
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: Cross-sectional study.
Methods: Transsexual women (n=62) and a control group of ovulating women (n=30) participated in this study. Questionnaires measuring sexual desire (sexual desire inventory) and relationship and sexual satisfaction (Maudsley Marital Questionnaire) were completed. Serum levels of total testosterone, LH and SHBG were measured in blood samples obtained at random in transsexual women and in the early follicular phase in ovulating women.
Results: The transsexual group had lower levels of total and calculated free testosterone (both P<0.001) than the ovulating women. HSDD was reported in 34% of the transsexual and 23% of the ovulating women (P=0.30). Both groups reported similar levels of sexual desire (P=0.97). For transsexual women, no significant correlation was found between sexual desire and total (P=0.64) or free testosterone (P=0.82). In ovulating women, these correlations were significant (P=0.006, resp. P=0.003).
Conclusions: HSDD is reported in one-third of transsexual women. This prevalence is not substantially different from controls, despite markedly lower (free) testosterone levels, which argues against a major role of testosterone in this specific group.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The objective of this study was to assess the prevalence of HSDD and the association between serum androgens and sexual desire in transsexual women. Considering the ongoing debate on both topics in women in general, a control group of community dwelling women was included. The hypothesis was that the transsexual women would have lower serum androgens in comparison with the control group – due to the continuous oestrogen replacement and the lack of an ovarian androgen source. Considering a possible association between androgens and sexual desire, a higher prevalence of HSDD was expected to be seen in the transsexual group.
| Materials and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Since the definition of HSDD in the Diagnostic and Stastical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) has provoked serious criticism (12), this study set out to work in accordance with the Sexual Function Health Council's consensus definition (13) dated 1998. This interdisciplinary team defined HSDD as the persistent or recurrent deficiency (or absence) of sexual fantasies, thoughts, desire for sexual activity (alone or with a partner) and the inability to respond to sexual cues that would be expected to trigger responsive sexual desire. These symptoms need to be causing personal distress.
In order to make a correct estimate of the prevalence of HSDD according to the above definition, a distinction was made in the questionnaires between spontaneous sexual desire and responsive sexual desire. This was explained as follows: some women experience spontaneous sexual desire (meaning having sexual thoughts, dreams, fantasies or initiating sexual activity). Other women mainly experience sexual desire when approached or touched by their partner or when perceiving sexual stimuli from a book or television, called responsive sexual desire. Another group of women experience both at different times. Two questions were asked about the frequency of spontaneous and responsive sexual desire (never/rarely, from time to time, often/usually). A third question (Is your sexual life hampered by problems of sexual desire felt by either yourself or by your partner?) reflected the presence of personal distress caused by potential problems concerning sexual desire. The participants could indicate a problem with too much/little sexual desire in themselves/their partner. We defined the diagnosis of HSDD (nominal variable) as follows: when a participant indicated that she never/rarely experienced either spontaneous or responsive sexual desire, and that her sexual life was hampered by a lack of sexual desire within herself and that this lack caused her distress.
Study population
Between January and October 2005, 62 transsexual and 30 ovulating women were recruited. Transsexual women on continuous oestrogen replacement were mainly reached through their follow-up visits to the Department of Sexology and Gender Problems (University Hospital Ghent, Belgium) (37%) and the Center for Gender Dysphoria (VU University Medical Center Amsterdam, The Netherlands) (45.2%). Since both the Flemish and the Dutch centres work according to similar diagnostic criteria in treating transsexual patients, the comparability of all recruited patients was guaranteed. Eleven transsexual women (17.7%) responded to banners on transgender community web sites and participated through a local laboratory in The Netherlands. The majority of transsexual women used transdermal oestradiol (mainly in gel form resulting in a 3.0 mg daily dose of oestradiol) or oral oestradiolvalerate (1–4 mg; 40.3 and 33.9%). The remaining participants used oral conjugated oestrogens (11.3%) or ethinyloestradiol (9.7%).
The control group of ovulating women was recruited through posters in the University Hospital of Ghent and consisted mainly of staff and students. Eligible participants were healthy women between 18 and 45 years of age. Exclusion criteria were use of steroidal contraception (combination pill, mini-pill, vaginal ring, contraceptive patch or progestin intrauteine device), medication possibly influencing androgen levels or sexual desire (like antidepressants or glucocorticoids) and other confounders for SHBG, such as alcoholism, cirrhosis, Cushing syndrome, and hyper- and hypothyroidism (14). We chose not to include isogender women who have been oophorectomized and treated with oestrogens in our control group as this is the first study to address sexual desire in relation to androgens in transsexuals and we aimed to describe the difference in androgen status between groups caused by the presence/absence of ovaries. Table 1 shows characteristics of both groups. Because of the age criterion in the ovulating women, both groups differed significantly in age (P<0.001).
|
A web site was designed where participants read about the background and objectives of the study to guarantee an informed consent. They completed questionnaires on sexual desire and relationship/sexual satisfaction online and subsequently contacted the research team for the withdrawal of a morning blood sample. A minority of the Dutch transsexual women received a package which would allow their general practitioner or a local clinical laboratory to draw a morning blood sample. This package contained all necessary medical material as well as the instructions for the participant and their general practitioner or local laboratory to perform the blood draw correctly and without any cost. After the blood collection, serum and red blood cells were separated locally. A courier company immediately transported the serum to the University Hospital of Ghent (Belgium) where it was stored at –80 °C until analysis. Most transsexual women, however, were recruited at their follow-up visits to one of the two participating centres and had a venous blood sample collected between 0800 and 1200 h at their centre. They subsequently filled out the questionnaires online. All transsexual women had their blood sample drawn at random, regardless of the timing of oestrogen intake. All Flemish ovulating women had their blood drawn between 0800 and 1200 h in the early follicular phase (third or fourth day after the start of menstruation).
This study complied with the recommendations of the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the Ethical Committee of the Ghent University Hospital.
Measures
Sexual desire
The Dutch version of the 14-item sexual desire inventory (15) was used to measure sexual desire, defined as an interest in sexual activity, as a cognitive variable. The scale measures the frequency and strength of thoughts in regards to seeking out or being receptive to sexual stimuli. For the frequency-items, participants chose one out of the seven options. For the strength-items, participants scored their sexual desire on a 9-point Likert scale ranging from 0 (no desire) to 8 (strong desire). The participants were asked to take the previous month as a reference. Adding items resulted in a score for dyadic sexual desire (interest in behaving sexually with a partner) and solitary sexual desire (interest in behaving sexually by oneself). The sexual desire inventory has a good reliability and validity (15). Internal consistency was high, in the group of transsexual (Cronbach's
=0.93) and ovulating women (Cronbach's
=0.92).
Sexual and relationship satisfaction
The Dutch version of the 20-item Maudsley Marital Questionnaire (16) was used to measure relationship, sexual and general life satisfaction. Only participants with a steady partner filled it out. Every item is scored on a Likert scale from 0 to 8. The participants were asked to take the previous 2 weeks as a reference. On all subscales, a higher score indicates more problems. The Maudsley Marital Questionnaire has good reliability and validity (15). The internal consistency was high as well in the group of transsexual (Cronbach's
=0.84) and ovulating women (Cronbach's
=0.87).
Diagnosis of HSDD At the time this study was conducted, no validated questionnaires were available to establish an HSDD diagnosis. Working with the consensus definition by Basson et al. (13), a very strict adaptation was made as described above.
Hormone assays Serum testosterone was assayed in 2 ml serum samples with an in-house RIA in duplicate after ether extraction followed by paper chromatography (17, 18); the intra- and inter-assay coefficients of variation for this assay were 5.6% (at a concentration of 35 ng/dl, i.e. 1.21 nmol/l) and 8.5% (at a concentration of 25 ng/dl, i.e. 0.87 nmol/l) respectively and the lower limit of quantification was 2 ng/dl (0.07 nmol/l). Commercial kits for RIA were used to determine the serum concentrations of SHBG (Orion Diagnostica, Espoo, Finland) and DHEA sulphate (DSL Inc., Webster, TX, USA); the intra-assay coefficients of variation were between 2.5 and 8.3% and between 3.1 and 5.6% for SHBG and DHEA-S respectively. For all measurements, all samples from transsexual women and controls were assayed in a same assay run. Serum free testosterone was calculated from the total serum hormone concentration, serum SHBG and serum albumin, using a validated equation derived from the mass action law (19).
Statistical analysis
Since the distribution of the dependent variables (sexual desire, sexual/relationship satisfaction) did not follow a normal distribution, non-parametric Mann–Whitney U tests were used to test between-group differences of these ordinal variables. A
2 test was used to compare the nominal variable (diagnosis of HSDD) between both groups. Partial correlations tested the association between levels of testosterone and sexual desire.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All participants completed the sexual desire inventory reflecting solitary and dyadic sexual desire. As shown in Table 2, there were no significant differences between ovulating and transsexual women, either in solitary sexual desire (P=0.97) or in dyadic sexual desire (P=0.26).
|
One-sample t-tests showed that the control group did not differ significantly from the normal female population (18) (relationship satisfaction: t(20)=–0.18, P=0.86; sexual satisfaction: t(20)=0.50, P=0.62; general life satisfaction: t(20)=0.11, P=0.91), confirming its representativeness. Transsexual women reported significantly less sexual satisfaction (P=0.002) than ovulating women. Regarding relationship and general life satisfaction (P=0.82 and P=0.55), transsexual and ovulating women did not differ significantly.
Prevalence of HSDD
HSDD was diagnosed in 33.9% of transsexual and in 23.3% of ovulating women. Although the percentage is higher in the transsexual group, there was no difference in the prevalence of HSDD (
2(1)=1.06, P=0.30) between both the groups. Our hypothesis concerning the frequency of HSDD was thus not confirmed. Furthermore, these percentages did not differ significantly from the general female population (25.6%) (11) (95% confidence interval, 22.1–45.7%).
Hormonal data
In Table 3, serum concentrations of SHBG, DHEA-S, free testosterone and total testosterone are presented. In both the groups, all concentrations were as expected physiologically. Our hypothesis concerning the serum concentrations of androgens was thus confirmed. The levels of total testosterone and calculated free testosterone were significantly (both P<0.001) lower in transsexual women when compared with those of the ovulating women. More specifically, 66.1% of transsexual women had levels of total testosterone below P25 in ovulating women (P25=23.88 ng/dl; 0.8 nmol/l). For calculated free testosterone, 59.7% of transsexual women had levels below P25 in ovulating women (P25=0.28 ng/dl; 0.01 nmol/l). Two ANCOVAs showed that these lower levels were a main effect of group and not of the higher age of the transsexual group (F(1)=12.573, P=0.001 for total testosterone and F(1)=9.235, P=0.003 for free testosterone). Serum levels of SHBG (P=1.00) and DHEA-S (P=0.57) did not differ between both the groups.
|
Association between sexual desire and hormone levels
With the age of the transsexual women being higher than those of the ovulating women, and the known age-related decline in levels of DHEA-S (20, 21), the correlations between androgen levels and measures of sexual desire (Table 4) have been corrected for age by using partial correlations. In transsexual women, no significant relation was found between androgen levels and measures of sexual desire. However, in the ovulating women a significant positive correlation was found between solitary sexual desire and levels of total testosterone (r=0.50, P=0.006) and free testosterone (r=0.53, P=0.003). In both the groups, no significant differences in serum concentrations of DHEA-S, total testosterone or free testosterone were found between participants with and without HSDD (data not shown). In the transsexual women, there was no relation between having an HSDD diagnosis and having a free testosterone level below P25 in ovulating women (
2(1)=0.25, P=0.61).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Transsexual women experience sexual desire of similar frequency and intensity as ovulating women. Nevertheless, there seems to be a general sexual discontent in transsexual women such as the one that can be gathered from the lower sexual satisfaction this group experiences in its sexual partnerships. Since sexual satisfaction was not the focus of this study, we were not able to explore the reasons behind this.
The serum concentrations of DHEA-S are comparable in transsexual and ovulating women, indicating a similar level of adrenal androgen production. Serum concentrations of total testosterone measured by RIA following extraction and chromatographic separation and calculated free testosterone are, as expected, markedly lower in the transsexual women. In 59.7% of the transsexual women, concentrations remain below P25 of free testosterone found in ovulating women. In an earlier study, 32.1% of transsexual women had serum levels of free testosterone within the expected female range (direct RIA method used) (8). According to the same criterion, this is 35.5% in the present study.
In the transsexual women, we could not establish an association between sexual desire and androgens. In the ovulating women, a positive association was observed: higher serum concentrations of total testosterone and free testosterone accompany a higher frequency and intensity of solitary sexual desire. This result is in line with observational research in premenopausal women where an association exists between free testosterone and sexual desire (3). The absence of this association in transsexual women could have several reasons. First, the majority has very low levels of (free) testosterone. This complicates finding a relation with sexual desire. Second, the profound decrease in testosterone levels transsexual women experienced during hormonal and surgical sex reassignment could play a role. It is possible that such a decrease demands a certain sexual reconditioning from the individual and the partnership. Research on surgical menopausal women has described – if to a lesser extent – somewhat similar events; removal of the ovaries causes a decrease in testosterone levels and sexual desire (22, 23, 24, 25). This psychological process of adjusting to a lower serum level could be of influence on the association between testosterone and sexual desire. Third, not only androgens play a role in sexual motivation. It is very well possible that the relief of finally being in the desired body and being socially accepted as a woman causes a healthy sexual appetite despite very low testosterone levels. Fourth, the functionality and aesthetics of the new genitals could have their influence on sexual satisfaction and possibly on sexual desire.
As to the limitations of this study, we have no information on the used method of non-hormonal contraception in the ovulating group, making it impossible to investigate this potential influence on sexual desire. Also, the subtle nuances of transsexual women's sexual desire might not have been adequately measured as the questionnaires were designed for women in general, even though they did allow detection of differences in sexual satisfaction. Furthermore, despite the fact that we were able to study a substantial number of transsexual women, and that the findings for our control group are in good agreement with those for the general population, the power of the comparison between transsexual and control women was limited. Nevertheless, the observations in this study converge to indicate that low testosterone does not play a prominent role in low sexual desire in transsexual women; i.e. a markedly high prevalence of low (free) testosterone in the transsexual women is accompanied by an at most modest increase of the prevalence of HSDD, whereas within this group, there is no relationship between androgen levels and indices of sexual desire. Measurement of low testosterone in women is technically difficult and has been an impediment in defining a clinical syndrome of androgen deficiency in women (1). In the present study, we addressed this technical problem by extracting testosterone from an adequately large, 2 ml serum sample and using a well-validated method involving a chromatographic separation step.
In conclusion, HSDD is reported in one-third of transsexual women. This prevalence is not substantially different from controls and reports from the general population. The levels of (free) testosterone in transsexual women were found to be at or below the lower end of the spectrum for (free) testosterone seen in the control group. No apparent association exists between these levels and the complaints of low sexual desire patients experience, which argues against a major role of (free) testosterone in this specific group. These observations should therefore be broadened by studies in the psychological and social field to help explain possible mediating factors.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-androstan-3-one, 4-androstene-3, 17-dione, dehydroepiandrosterone, 17-hydroxyprogesterone and progesterone and its application to human male plasma. Journal of Steroid Biochemistry 1976; 7: 1–10.[CrossRef][Web of Science][Medline]18. Vermeulen A & Verdonck L. Sex hormone concentrations in postmenopausal women. Relation to obesity, fat mass, age and years menopause. Clinical Endocrinology 1978; 9: 407–412.[Medline]19. Vermeulen A, Verdonck L & Kaufman JM. A critical evaluation of simple methods for the estimation of free testosterone in serum. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 1999; 84: 3666–3672.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |